Key Lime Pie Cookie - 4oz
Choose an available window
Available in 2 availability windows. Next up: Saturday Pickup • Jun 27, 2026.
A bright, citrusy escape in every bite.
Refresh your palate with our Sourdough Key Lime Pie Cookies. This isn't just a lemon cookie—it’s a carefully crafted tribute to the classic tropical dessert. We use our sourdough starter to create a soft, melt-in-your-mouth base that perfectly balances the tartness of the citrus.
We’ve packed these cookies with authentic island flavor:
The Zest & Juice: We use fresh lime zest and real key lime juice to give the dough a vibrant, natural zing that wakes up your taste buds.
The White Chocolate Dip: Each cookie is hand-dipped in creamy white chocolate, providing a smooth, velvety sweetness that mimics the silky texture of pie filling.
The Pie Crust Finish: For the perfect finishing touch, we garnish each cookie with graham cracker pie crumbs, adding that essential buttery crunch we all love.
The Sourdough Secret: While these aren't "sour," the sourdough adds a subtle depth that makes the citrus pop. It creates a tender, shortbread-like texture that holds up beautifully to the rich white chocolate coating.
The "Island Style" Tip
These cookies are incredibly refreshing when served at room temperature, but for a true "pie" experience, try chilling them in the fridge for 20 minutes before serving. The cold white chocolate and bright lime flavor make for the perfect cool treat on a warm afternoon.
Select Your Window
Add to Cart
Review details in your cart and choose your payment method at checkout.
We respond quickly to confirm availability, pickup details, and payment.
Prefer personal service?
Use Contact for Next Availability when you need help with:
- Coordinating delivery or pickup beyond the default options
- Shipping inquiries (when available)
- Custom designs, flavors, or dietary requests
- Large or recurring orders for events and wholesale